- A new review found that highly engineered consumables could be just as habit-forming as cigarettes.
- Scientists found that these foods are engineered to heighten pleasure and speed up the delivery of rewarding ingredients.
- The habit-forming nature of such products suggests they drive uncontrollable eating and disrupt natural hunger cues.
- The researchers recommend that ultraprocessed foods ought to be governed by controls akin to those for tobacco products.
Right now, there is no single universal description of UPFs. Some people define them as foods that include ingredients you are unlikely to have in a home kitchen, such as stabilizers and additives.
A lot of dietitians use the NOVA system to define UPFs. This refers to foods that contain “formulations of components, mostly of exclusive industrial use, usually produced by a series of factory processes and methods.”
A recent analysis featured in The Millbank Quarterly proposed that UPFs could be as addictive as cigarettes.
“I concur with this study, as UPFs are deliberately designed to be highly appealing to many consumers,” commented a weight loss specialist who was not involved in the study.
A study from last year calculates that over 73% of the foods available in the America is classified as ultraprocessed.
“Cigarettes and UPFs are not just whole foods but scientifically formulated consumable products created purposely to increase biological and psychological reward and compulsive consumption,” noted the review’s authors.
Are UPFs Habit-Forming?
This analysis synthesized insights from addiction, historical health policy, and nutrition in order to highlight textural and compositional characteristics that increase the rewarding nature of both cigarettes and ultraprocessed foods.
“It’s not all people is ‘addicted’’ to these foods, but for a meaningful minority, they cause typical habit-forming patterns: intense desires, loss of control, and persistent consumption even with negative health effects,” commented a preventive cardiology dietitian.
“These foods are intentionally designed with processed carbohydrates, extra oils, sodium, and flavor enhancers to optimize pleasure and ongoing intake, and the industry employs persuasive advertising strategies, particularly targeting children,” she added.
The authors focused on five key areas:
- rapid absorption
- pleasure-based design, or creating products to be extremely pleasurable
- dose optimization
- widespread availability
- deceptive reformulation, or “wellness branding”
It was observed that, similar to cigarettes, ultraprocessed foods are carefully calibrated to provide the optimal amount of sweetness.
“Refined carbohydrates stimulate dopamine production via the vagus nerve, whereas lipids do so through fat detection in the gut,” the researchers explained.
“… UPFs with significant amounts of processed carbs and extra oils are some of the most strongly reinforcing foods in the contemporary food supply. Notably this processed carb and fat mix is virtually absent in whole foods.”
How these foods quickly deliver “feel-good” substances to the mind makes them likely habit-forming, in a comparable way to tobacco.
The paper stated that while cigarettes are engineered to provide nicotine rapidly, ultraprocessed foods are formulated to be broken down and absorbed quickly, as they typically have minimal fiber. This allows for the system to metabolize lipids and carbohydrates faster.
Authors also note that UPFs give intentional flavor bursts that dissipate rapidly and mouthfeels that dissolve easily. This collectively works to trigger increased pleasure signals and encourages individuals to consume additional amounts.
‘Health Washing’ in Cigarettes, UPFs
Based on the review, both the tobacco and food industries have historically employed a tactic called “wellness branding.”
This refers to when products are advertised and altered to generate an illusion of reduced harm while maintaining the core of their qualities.
Health washing in the tobacco industry became popular in the 1950s with the advent of filters on smokes.
These were sold as safety features that would trap tar and particles prior to they entered the lungs. Actually, these tips offer little meaningful protection.
However, people often adjusted by inhaling deeper or increasing consumption, which negated any reduction in harmful intake.
Food manufacturers has adopted a similar strategy. It uses packaging claims like “reduced fat” or “no sugar added” to promote UPFs.
However, these foods often retain the same highly reinforcing formulations. The issue is that these changes present a superficial appearance of health while the product’s habit-forming nature and metabolic harms persist unchanged.
Ought Ultraprocessed Foods Be Regulated?
The researchers noted at the conclusion of their paper that nourishment and smoking products are not the same thing.
Nevertheless, they warned that certain UPFs act like highly optimized products rather than real nourishment. They recommended that health regulations should reflect this distinction.
“Tobacco offers a cautionary tale, and smoking regulations offers a source of potential,” the authors wrote.
Because of regulations, smoking rates in the United States have declined and have “reshaped public perception of smoking and eroded confidence in the industry.”
“I believe increased education about the harmful effects of UPFs is essential to lower general consumption and improve public health. The strategies used to curb cigarette consumption have been effective and may be a useful blueprint for ultra-processed foods as well,” said one expert.
“It is not my view UPFs ought to be controlled precisely like tobacco, but they certainly deserve stronger, smoking policy-based measures: marketing restrictions, obvious front-of-package labeling, tighter rules on wellness assertions, and restrictions in schools or hospitals,” noted another dietitian.
The authors pointed out to people that lightly altered and whole foods have sustained human health for thousands of years.